Home  

Book Recommendation

Aspergers Clinic
  Diagnostic Evaluations

Assessments
  ABLLS-R
 
ADHD
 
Aspergers
  Autism
  Dyslexia
 
FBAs
  Indep. Ed. Evals (IEE)
 
Learning Disabilities

  
Intake Packet

In-Home Services
  ABA/VBA
  Problem Behaviors
  Sleep Service
  Toilet Training

  
In-Home
    Intake Packet

Consultation
  Behavior Plans (BIP)
  Indep. Ed. Evals (IEE)
  IEP - Consultation

Workshops
  Staff Training
  Parent Verbal
 
Therapist Program

About Us

Consultants

Contact Us

Directions
  Nearby Accommodations

Fees

Forms

Insurance
  ● TriCare Change
  ●TriCare UPDATE

  ● Retired TriCare -ABA 
  ●
Insurance Policy PDF

 
Is ABA Experimental?
 
Resources in seeking
     Insurance support for
     ABA services

Open Ga Autism List

Public Service

Referral Information

Staff Hiring

Support Groups
  Open Ga Autism List

Testimonials

Articles  
  Sleep - Not Optional
  As a Parent - ABA
  Aspergers & Depression
  ABA, Retirees, and TriCare
  Briefing the Teacher
  Does RU Certify
        Therapists?
  BCBA-D What is it?
  BCABA - Independent?
  How to answer when
  insurance says ABA
  is experimental.
  EIBI and Cost
  "The Autism Puzzle"
  What is BCBA anyway?
  What is the ABLLS-R?
  ASD Evaluations
  SLP & ABA
  Sign vs. PECS
  Diagnosis-Eligibility
  Release Records
  NAS on Autism
  Sleep Tips
  Hire an ABA?
  ADHD or Sleep?
  Aggression
  Communication
  FBA
  NASP & FBAs
  Rx data sharing
  More than Rx needed
  Social Maladjustment
  A good Psych Report?

Links
  Aspergers
  Autism
    Support Groups
 
Behavioral

  Consumer Resources
  Education
  Learning Disorders
  Medical  
  Psychology
  Specific Disorders

 

Discussion:
Topic of the Day

dnastranda_gm.gif (23073 bytes)

When More than Medication is Appropriate

The issue of the "origin" of a problem behavior is not easily resolved - even for disorders that are clearly organic in origin.  Does this sound strange to you?  If it doesn't, stop reading here.  If it does, keep reading - this is a tough topic.

It is a truism that all behavior is organic in origin - we are all organic organisms and we are the actors who behave and ipso facto all our behavior is organic.  The problem isn't with the truism - it is with the follow-on belief that if every behavior is organic in origin then every intervention (or treatment) must also be organic (or medical/pharmaceutical).  I chose PANDAS (Pediatric Autoimmune Neuropsychiatric Disorders Associated with Streptococcal infection) to help illustrate this issue because PANDAS is a new theory about why some children rapidly develop Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder and/or a Tic Disorder which holds that this disorder is totally organic in origin.  The data to date, despite this being a new (fewer than 5 years) hypothesis about rapid onset OCD, are falling into place pointing to a pathology involving a combination of an underlying genetic susceptibility that is triggered by Group A beta-hemolytic streptococcal bacteria which produce antibodies that effect the basal ganglia (a structure in the brain) that results in OCD or a Tic Disorder in pre-pubescent children.  Another disorder which has its origins in the brain and is therefore organic is Landau-Kleffner Syndrome (LKS).  LKS is a rare form of childhood epilepsy which results in severe behavior and language disturbances.  All children who have LKS have a history of abnormal electrical activity in the brain and about two-thirds have observable seizures.

Both these disorders have a suspected organic origin (for PANDAS its an infection and for LKS its seizures).  Each of these disorders result in terrible changes in the child's pre-morbid (before the disease) behavior and overall functioning.  In the case of PANDAS you see either predominantly repetitive motor behavior (Compulsions), perseveration on thoughts (Obsessions), or involuntary motor movement (Tics).  With LKS what you see is a loss of both receptive and expressive language and in many cases a very significant increase in aggressive behaviors.  The child can literally no longer understand what their ears still hear and their ability to speak is also severely reduced.   There is no commonly accepted medical treatment for PANDAS as yet.  The damage is done to the basal ganglia which results in the change in behavior.  Some have offered antibiotics as a treatment but the literature indicates that this works only if given early and then only in some cases, others have offered such radical treatments as total plasma replacement.  These treatments more often than not fail because the origin of the problems is in the past - the infection caused antibodies which acted on the basal ganglia and damaged it.  The damage has been done and antibiotics do not repair the brain they merely help the body clear away infections.  For LKS there appears to be a developing standard for treatment - an anti-seizure medication (lamictal, depakene, etc.) and corticosteroids in combination.  In both instances, PANDAS and LKS, the approaches are medical/pharmacological because the underlying cause is seen as organic.

In the case of PANDAS there is no established medical treatment that addresses the theorized underlying damage to the basal ganglia of the brain.  With LKS, in many children, the combination of an anti-seizure medication and a course of corticosteroids in combination results in significant improvement in the language and behavior of the child.  In neither case is the treatment solely medical.  Since there is no medical treatment that addresses the theorized underlying cause for PANDAS what are we left to do?  Behavior Therapy has offered treatments for OCD and many Tic Disorder since the mid-1970's which are empirically supported by a wide range of research across multiple investigators in a variety of countries with all age groups.  Wait, how can you use a behavioral intervention with a disorder that is organic?  Are you trying to be mean to the child - it's not their fault?  No, no one is trying to be mean to the child.  While there are some drugs that have some documented efficacy in helping deal with OCD, none of them has been researched with children with OCD for either efficacy or long-term side-effects specifically on children.  Additionally, for many children such drugs do not solve the problem.  With these facts in mind the question becomes - Do we let the child go on with these very disturbing (and draining) behaviors or do we try a well-documented combination of environmental manipulations and training to stop these problems?  So, in the case of PANDAS it appears that even though it is theorized to be organic there is a significant place for non-medical, purely behavioral, interventions to alleviate suffering in the children with resulting OCD and Tic Disorders.

On the other hand there is LKS for which a relatively effective combination of medical treatments appear to have a good track record.  First, let me say that in my experience working with the children (and their families), with LKS appropriate diagnosis and treatment by a Neurologist specializing in children and rare disorders is essential.   I have seen too many LKS children who were seen by a generalist neurologist who totally missed the diagnosis - and on more than one occasion had never heard of LKS.   I have never seen a child with LKS recover significant portions of their language without some form of medical treatment (almost always the combination of drugs mentioned before).  It is also true in my experience (and there is some support for this in the literature on LKS) that the longer the delay in seeing an appropriate pediatric neurologist and getting treatment the lower the chances of significant recovery of language and improvement in behavior for the child.  However, I have also not seen a child recover their language completely (or nearly so) without focused support from a highly trained Speech-Language Pathologist.  In those children with LKS there is often a pronounced increase in aggressive behaviors.  Even with good medical intervention directed by a well informed pediatric neurologist these aggressive behaviors can continue (hopefully at lower intensity) without adequate behavior management in place.  So, in the case of LKS where there appears to be a clear organic cause (seizures in the temporal lobe(s)) and some growing consensus on treatment (anti-seizure plus corticosteroids) there remains the need for non-medical treatment as well (SLP and Behavior Management).

Caveats - there is no excuse for the lack of an adequate medical evaluation by the appropriately trained specialist when children demonstrate significant changes in functioning.  This paper is not intended to convey any other opinion or recommendation.  If your child has severe changes in behavior (or even mild ones that seem odd or difficult to understand) see your family physician immediately.  It is also my recommendation that if these changes involve language (its loss or degradation), memory, ability to relate or orient, or involuntary movements of any kind that you seek a consult and evaluation by a pediatric neurologist immediately.  If the pediatric neurologist tells you that it is not serious then no harm, but if you do not go ........  Remember that, for at least LKS, delays in obtaining appropriate treatment appear to seriously reduce the potential recovery for many children.


tips.gif (506 bytes)  Today's Resource Tips:   There are several links under "Rare Disorders" at the top of our "Specific Disorders" page that will help you find additional information on PANDAS and LKS.   Additionally, you may want to go to the LKS home page in the UK, the FOLKS webpage, or to the TEACCH page on LKS.

 

Copyright 1996-2016 Reinforcement Unlimited. All Rights Reserved
These pages are optimized for viewing in 800x600 format.
HIPAA Notice & Website Useage practices are available for viewing.

Our publications (online, email, or print) do not provide medical advice or a professional service. We are not engaged in providing any medical or professional advice or services through the publication or distribution of articles or comments on this site. Individuals with suspected or diagnosed disorders or syndromes, or any condition discussed on this site, should consult with a qualified professional for advice concerning treatment.  Please be advised that due to issus of confidentiality Reinforcement Unlimited, and its staff, will not correspond about specific children or their services via email or other electronic communication method.  If your inquiry is about a specific child's services please call the office at one of the numbers above.